Cookies, Pies & More

Beyond our custom cakes, we bake a full lineup of cookies, pies, pastries, rolls, and breads. Everything is made from scratch using recipes perfected over 25 years.

Cookies

Simple Cookies

$6.25/doz

Chocolate Chip · Holiday Sugar Cookie · Oatmeal Raisin · Peanut Butter · Sand Tart · Snickerdoodle

Specialty Cookies

$6.75/doz

Cherry Thumbprint · Chocolate Crinkle · Coconut Macaroons · Cream Cheese Daintie · Date Pinwheel · Iced Orange Drop Cookies · Italian Rum Butter Balls · Lemon Cheese Bars · Mexican Wedding · Peanut Butter Balls · Ricotta Cheese · Sour Cream Raisin Drop · Swedish Heirloom

Deluxe Cookies

$7.50/doz

Kiss Cookies · Nut Tassle · Peanut Butter Cup

Other Cookies & Items

Sally's White Velvet Cutouts$7.25/doz

Black Bottom Cheesecake Cups$1.85 each

Fruit Bars$0.95 each

Brownies$0.95 each

Baker's Choice Mixed Cookie Box$7.25/doz

A colorful spread of assorted cookies including thumbprints, crinkles, and sugar cookies from Lisa Becker's Bakery

Perfect for holidays, graduations, showers, office parties, or any gathering. Each tray features a beautiful assortment of our freshly baked cookies.

Small

3 dozen

$26

Medium

5 dozen

$39

Large

9 dozen

$67

A large cookie tray filled with dozens of beautifully arranged homemade cookies ready for a party

Specialty Pastries

Roski

$7.25/doz

Apricot · Cheese · Nut

Lady Locks

$7.25/doz

A beloved Pittsburgh-area classic with delicate flaky pastry and sweet cream filling.

Gobs

Chocolate and Pumpkin varieties. Old Fashion and Cream Cheese filling available on request.

Regular$1.60 each

Miniature$8.50/doz

Filled Cookies

Blueberry · Cherry · Raisin · Pineapple

Large$10.50/doz

Mini$8.50/doz

Rolls & Breads

Pumpkin Roll$11.00

Nut Roll$12.00

Cinnamon Rolls (half dozen)$6.00

Cinnamon Rolls (dozen)$11.00

Banana Nut, Pumpkin & Zucchini Bread$7.00

Dinner Rolls (dozen)$5.50

Bread (loaf)$5.50

Small Apple Dumplings$3.00 each

Pies

$12.00 & up

Coconut Creme

Chocolate Creme

Chocolate Peanut Butter Creme

Lemon Meringue

Key Lime

Butterscotch

Egg Custard

Coconut Egg Custard

Apple Crumb

Apple

Blackbottom Pecan Cheesecake

Peach

Blueberry

Fudge Brownie

Pumpkin

Pumpkin Crunch

Lemon Lush

Banana Creme

Insideout Boston Creme

Boston Creme

Upside Down Apple Walnut

Tollhouse Cookie Pie

Pecan

Cherry

Strawberry Creme

Graham Cracker

Peanut Butter Creme

Black Raspberry Creme

Cherry Creme

Blueberry Creme

German Chocolate

Graham Cracker Pudding

Eclair Pie

Oreo Crust

Mounds

Cookie Tiramisu

Chocolate Passion

Oreo Dirt Pie

Good to Know

Allergies: If allergies are a concern, please ask about alternative recipes. Gluten free products are available.

Custom requests: Any personal favorites not listed can be made upon request. Just give us a call!

Prices are subject to change. Please call to confirm current pricing and availability.

Place Your Order

Ready to order? Give us a call or reach out through our contact page. We recommend ordering at least 48 hours in advance for larger requests.

(814) 946-4964 Contact Us